跳過到頁腳內容
與其他組件的比較

Tesseract vs Microsoft OCR:面對面比較

Developers frequently have to choose between the Tesseract OCR tool and the Microsoft OCR engine when it comes to Optical Character Recognition (OCR) in C#. Despite having different capabilities, efficiency, integration, and ease, both are effective OCR tools for extracting text from photos or scanned documents. Within the framework of C# development, we will thoroughly examine the merits, drawbacks, and applicability of different OCR tools like Tesseract vs. Microsoft OCR in this article.

什麼是 OCR?

Optical Character Recognition is referred to as OCR. It's a technology that makes it possible to turn various document formats—like scanned image documents, PDF files, or digital camera photos—into editable and searchable data. To transform an image's forms and patterns into machine-readable text, different OCR tools such as Google Cloud Vision or Google Vision OCR analyze the images. By using this technique, users may fetch text from photographs and edit, search, and change the content just like they would with a digital document.

Tesseract OCR

Tesseract OCR is an open-source optical character recognition (OCR) engine, sometimes referred to as just Tesseract. Tesseract, which was initially created by Hewlett-Packard Laboratories in the 1980s and is now maintained by Google, is one of the most popular OCR engines in use today.

Tesseract's primary function is to identify text included in pictures or handling scanned documents and translate them into machine-readable text. This makes text editable, searchable, and manipulable by allowing users to extract text from a variety of sources, including scanned document analysis, photos, and PDF files.

Key features of Tesseract OCR

  • Open-Source: Tesseract is freely available for use, modification, and distribution by anybody under the terms of the Apache License 2.0. Its open-source design has greatly aided in its broad adoption and ongoing enhancement, thanks to community contributions.
  • Language Support: Tesseract is capable of recognizing more than 100 different scripts and character sets in addition to languages. It is appropriate for a wide range of OCR applications in various languages and geographical areas due to its multilingual capability.
  • Accuracy: Tesseract is well known for its excellent text recognition accuracy, particularly when set up correctly and trained with pertinent data. It can reliably extract text from photos with a variety of issues, including distorted angles, low quality, and inadequate illumination.
  • Options: Tesseract provides a great deal of configuration and customization options. For particular use cases, users can adjust several parameters to maximize OCR performance. Furthermore, Tesseract may be coupled with a variety of platforms and computer languages, such as Java, C++, Python, and C#, enabling developers to take advantage of its capabilities in a broad range of applications.
  • Tesseract undergoes constant development and maintenance, with new features added regularly to boost its accuracy, performance, and language support. Tesseract's open-source community supports its continuous development, guaranteeing that it will always be a state-of-the-art OCR tool.

Install Tesseract OCR For .NET

Installing Tesseract OCR on your computer is the first step. The official Tesseract GitHub repository is where you can get the Tesseract installer: https://github.com/tesseract-ocr/tesseract.

To install Tesseract OCR on your computer, follow the setup instructions that are specific to your operating system (Windows, macOS, or Linux). After Tesseract OCR is installed, use Visual Studio's NuGet Package Manager to add the Tesseract.NET wrapper to your C# project.

Navigate to Tools -> NuGet Package Manager -> Manage NuGet Packages for Solution after opening your C# project in Visual Studio. You should be able to locate the package named "Tesseract" or "Tesseract.NET" by searching for "Tesseract" in the NuGet Package Manager. To include the package in your project, choose it and click Install.

Tesseract vs Microsoft OCR (OCR Features Comparison): Figure 1 - Tesseract

Tesseract OCR using C#

Follow these steps to use Tesseract in your C# project:

using Tesseract;

class Program
{
    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        // Initialize the Tesseract engine with the path to your Tesseract installation and the desired language(s)
        using (var engine = new TesseractEngine(@"path_to_tesseract_folder", "eng", EngineMode.Default))
        {
            // Load the image from which to extract text
            using (var img = Pix.LoadFromFile("image.png"))
            {
                // Process the image and extract the text
                using (var page = engine.Process(img))
                {
                    // Get the extracted text
                    var text = page.GetText();
                    Console.WriteLine(text); // Print the extracted text
                }
            }
        }
    }
}
using Tesseract;

class Program
{
    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        // Initialize the Tesseract engine with the path to your Tesseract installation and the desired language(s)
        using (var engine = new TesseractEngine(@"path_to_tesseract_folder", "eng", EngineMode.Default))
        {
            // Load the image from which to extract text
            using (var img = Pix.LoadFromFile("image.png"))
            {
                // Process the image and extract the text
                using (var page = engine.Process(img))
                {
                    // Get the extracted text
                    var text = page.GetText();
                    Console.WriteLine(text); // Print the extracted text
                }
            }
        }
    }
}
Imports Tesseract

Friend Class Program
	Shared Sub Main(ByVal args() As String)
		' Initialize the Tesseract engine with the path to your Tesseract installation and the desired language(s)
		Using engine = New TesseractEngine("path_to_tesseract_folder", "eng", EngineMode.Default)
			' Load the image from which to extract text
			Using img = Pix.LoadFromFile("image.png")
				' Process the image and extract the text
				Using page = engine.Process(img)
					' Get the extracted text
					Dim text = page.GetText()
					Console.WriteLine(text) ' Print the extracted text
				End Using
			End Using
		End Using
	End Sub
End Class
$vbLabelText   $csharpLabel

To accomplish this, provide the location of your Tesseract installation directory and the language or languages you wish to utilize in the TesseractEngine constructor options. Replace "eng" with the language code for the language or languages you wish to use (e.g., "eng" for English) and "path_to_tesseract_folder" with the actual path to your Tesseract installation directory.

After setting up Tesseract in your C# project, you can now utilize its OCR features to extract text from pictures. The TesseractEngine instance can be used to process a picture once it has been loaded using the Pix class to extract text or run OCR on an image file, replacing "image.png" with the path of the image file.

What is Microsoft OCR?

Microsoft's Cognitive Services package includes Microsoft OCR, sometimes referred to as Microsoft Optical Character Recognition. Microsoft Azure offers a cloud-based optical character recognition (OCR) solution that can extract text from documents and photos with enhanced text recognition capabilities. Microsoft OCR uses deep neural networks and machine learning techniques to recognize text from a variety of sources with excellent accuracy.

關鍵功能

  • Integration with Azure Cognitive Services: Microsoft OCR functions in unison with Azure Cognitive Services, a collection of AI-powered Microsoft Azure APIs and services. With this connection, developers can easily integrate Microsoft OCR functions into applications and workflows by using REST APIs, SDKs, and client libraries.
  • High Accuracy and Performance: Because of its sophisticated machine learning models that have been trained on enormous datasets, Microsoft OCR provides text recognition with high accuracy and performance. With its ability to precisely extract text from photographs with intricate layouts and various typefaces, it is appropriate for a broad spectrum of OCR applications.
  • Scalability and Reliability: Microsoft OCR, a component of Azure Cognitive Services, provides scalability and dependability, making it appropriate for applications with different processing requirements. It can effectively manage high document quantities and multiple requests at once, guaranteeing uptime and stable performance.
  • Multilingual Support: Microsoft OCR, like other OCR programs, allows for multilingual recognition, allowing users to extract text from photos in a variety of languages and character sets. It is appropriate for worldwide applications with a variety of language needs thanks to its multilingual support.

You must combine Microsoft OCR with Azure Cognitive Services—more specifically, the Computer Vision API—to use it in a C# project. Here is how you can begin:

Create an Azure Account

You must create an Azure account if you don't already have one. You can create a free Azure account and have access to several services during the trial time.

Configure Azure Cognitive Services

The Computer Vision service in Azure Cognitive Services must be configured when you have an Azure account.

  • Open the Azure Portal.
  • Look up "Computer Vision" by clicking on "Create a resource".
  • Click "Create" after selecting the Computer Vision service.
  • To configure the service, choose the subscription and price tier by following the prompts.
  • After the service is built, go to the resource and save the subscription key and endpoint URL; you'll need them to verify the authenticity of your queries.

Install the Azure Cognitive Services SDK

Utilizing Microsoft Azure is possible. To communicate with the Computer Vision API in your C# project, use the CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision NuGet package.

Navigate to Tools -> NuGet Package Manager then Manage NuGet Packages for Solution after opening your C# project in Visual Studio.

Install the package by doing a search for "Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision".

Tesseract vs Microsoft OCR (OCR Features Comparison): Figure 2 - Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision

Microsoft OCR Using C#

After installing the SDK, you may use the Computer Vision API to do OCR. An introductory example of using the Computer Vision API to do OCR on an image can be found below:

using System;
using Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision;
using Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision.Models;
using System.Threading.Tasks;

class Program
{
    static async Task Main(string[] args)
    {
        // Set your endpoint and subscription key for authentication
        var endpoint = "YOUR_ENDPOINT";
        var subscriptionKey = "YOUR_SUBSCRIPTION_KEY";

        // Create a new instance of the ComputerVisionClient
        var client = new ComputerVisionClient(new ApiKeyServiceClientCredentials(subscriptionKey))
        {
            Endpoint = endpoint
        };

        // Perform OCR on the specified image
        var result = await client.RecognizePrintedTextInStreamAsync(true, "image.png");

        // Iterate over the results and print the recognized text
        foreach (var region in result.Regions)
        {
            foreach (var line in region.Lines)
            {
                foreach (var word in line.Words)
                {
                    Console.WriteLine(word.Text);
                }
            }
        }
    }
}
using System;
using Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision;
using Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision.Models;
using System.Threading.Tasks;

class Program
{
    static async Task Main(string[] args)
    {
        // Set your endpoint and subscription key for authentication
        var endpoint = "YOUR_ENDPOINT";
        var subscriptionKey = "YOUR_SUBSCRIPTION_KEY";

        // Create a new instance of the ComputerVisionClient
        var client = new ComputerVisionClient(new ApiKeyServiceClientCredentials(subscriptionKey))
        {
            Endpoint = endpoint
        };

        // Perform OCR on the specified image
        var result = await client.RecognizePrintedTextInStreamAsync(true, "image.png");

        // Iterate over the results and print the recognized text
        foreach (var region in result.Regions)
        {
            foreach (var line in region.Lines)
            {
                foreach (var word in line.Words)
                {
                    Console.WriteLine(word.Text);
                }
            }
        }
    }
}
Imports System
Imports Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision
Imports Microsoft.Azure.CognitiveServices.Vision.ComputerVision.Models
Imports System.Threading.Tasks

Friend Class Program
	Shared Async Function Main(ByVal args() As String) As Task
		' Set your endpoint and subscription key for authentication
		Dim endpoint = "YOUR_ENDPOINT"
		Dim subscriptionKey = "YOUR_SUBSCRIPTION_KEY"

		' Create a new instance of the ComputerVisionClient
		Dim client = New ComputerVisionClient(New ApiKeyServiceClientCredentials(subscriptionKey)) With {.Endpoint = endpoint}

		' Perform OCR on the specified image
		Dim result = Await client.RecognizePrintedTextInStreamAsync(True, "image.png")

		' Iterate over the results and print the recognized text
		For Each region In result.Regions
			For Each line In region.Lines
				For Each word In line.Words
					Console.WriteLine(word.Text)
				Next word
			Next line
		Next region
	End Function
End Class
$vbLabelText   $csharpLabel

To perform OCR on an image file, substitute "image.png" in the code sample above with the path to the image file. This code will retrieve the recognized text from the image by sending it to the Computer Vision API. The endpoint URL and subscription key you received after configuring the Computer Vision service in Azure Cognitive Services should be substituted for "YOUR_ENDPOINT" and "YOUR_SUBSCRIPTION_KEY".

What is IronOCR?

Developers may incorporate text recognition capabilities into their C# or VB.NET applications with IronOCR, a .NET OCR library. It offers a user-friendly API for text extraction from PDFs, pictures, and other types of media. Iron Software, a software development business that specializes in .NET components and libraries, creates and maintains IronOCR.

關鍵功能 of IronOCR

  • Simple Integration: You may incorporate IronOCR into your C# or VB.NET projects with ease by utilizing NuGet packages or by accessing the library directly in your project.
  • Versatile OCR: IronOCR can recognize text from a wide range of sources, such as screenshots, scanned documents, PDF files, and photographs. It is capable of handling several image types, including BMP, TIFF, PNG, and JPEG.
  • Accurate Text Recognition: IronOCR achieves excellent text recognition accuracy by utilizing sophisticated OCR algorithms. Text in photographs with different resolutions, fonts, and backgrounds may be reliably extracted using it.
  • Support for Multiple Languages: IronOCR is appropriate for multilingual applications because it can recognize multiple languages. It enables customized language training and comes with built-in language packs for popular languages.
  • PDF Text Extraction: Scanned and image-based PDFs can both have their text extracted by IronOCR. When removing text from PDF documents, it can maintain the content's original formatting and layout.
  • Image Preprocessing: Before OCR processing, IronOCR can improve the quality of incoming images through image preprocessing features. This covers tasks like deskewing, contrast modification, and noise reduction.

IronOCR Using C#

Here is a basic C# example using IronOCR:

// Create an instance of IronTesseract
var Ocr = new IronTesseract(); // nothing to configure
// Set the language and Tesseract version to be used for OCR
Ocr.Language = OcrLanguage.EnglishBest;
Ocr.Configuration.TesseractVersion = TesseractVersion.Tesseract5;

// Prepare the image input and perform OCR
using (var Input = new OcrInput())
{
    // Add the image for OCR processing
    Input.AddImage(@"Demo.png");
    // Read the text from the image
    var Result = Ocr.Read(Input);
    // Print the recognized text
    Console.WriteLine(Result.Text);
    Console.ReadKey(); // Wait for user input before closing
}
// Create an instance of IronTesseract
var Ocr = new IronTesseract(); // nothing to configure
// Set the language and Tesseract version to be used for OCR
Ocr.Language = OcrLanguage.EnglishBest;
Ocr.Configuration.TesseractVersion = TesseractVersion.Tesseract5;

// Prepare the image input and perform OCR
using (var Input = new OcrInput())
{
    // Add the image for OCR processing
    Input.AddImage(@"Demo.png");
    // Read the text from the image
    var Result = Ocr.Read(Input);
    // Print the recognized text
    Console.WriteLine(Result.Text);
    Console.ReadKey(); // Wait for user input before closing
}
' Create an instance of IronTesseract
Dim Ocr = New IronTesseract() ' nothing to configure
' Set the language and Tesseract version to be used for OCR
Ocr.Language = OcrLanguage.EnglishBest
Ocr.Configuration.TesseractVersion = TesseractVersion.Tesseract5

' Prepare the image input and perform OCR
Using Input = New OcrInput()
	' Add the image for OCR processing
	Input.AddImage("Demo.png")
	' Read the text from the image
	Dim Result = Ocr.Read(Input)
	' Print the recognized text
	Console.WriteLine(Result.Text)
	Console.ReadKey() ' Wait for user input before closing
End Using
$vbLabelText   $csharpLabel

We can extract data from the image with the highest OCR accuracy by using the code mentioned above. Additionally, IronOCR facilitates the conversion of text extracted from documents into editable file formats, including Word. The scanned document can also be turned into a searchable PDF by us. With IronOCR, the outcome can be stored in various OCR output formats. To learn more about the code refer here.

圖源:

Tesseract vs Microsoft OCR (OCR Features Comparison): Figure 3 - Input Image

結果:

Tesseract vs Microsoft OCR (OCR Features Comparison): Figure 4 - Console Output

結論

In conclusion, Tesseract and Microsoft OCR, each with unique advantages and disadvantages, provide strong OCR capabilities for C# developers. Because Tesseract offers customization and flexibility, it is a good choice for applications that require a great deal of fine-tuning. However, Microsoft OCR is the best option for C# applications that need sophisticated text recognition capabilities because of its high accuracy, scalability, and seamless connection with Azure services. For their C# projects, developers should weigh their individual needs, modification requirements, and financial limits before deciding between Tesseract and Microsoft OCR.

Lastly, IronOCR is a remarkable OCR solution that offers outstanding integration, flexibility, and accuracy. Because of its unparalleled accuracy, advanced algorithms, and capacity to identify a wide range of document types, IronOCR is the best OCR solution currently on the market. Because IronOCR integrates smoothly across numerous documents and common computer languages, it ensures developer accessibility while maintaining an intuitive interface.

You can try the affordable development edition of IronOCR for free, and if you buy the IronOCR package, you'll get a lifetime license. With a starting price of $799, the IronOCR bundle is an excellent value as it offers a single price for several devices. To learn more about the cost, visit the IronOCR website. Click this link to learn more about Iron Software products.

[{i:(Tesseract and Microsoft OCR are registered trademarks of their respective owners. This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Tesseract or Microsoft OCR. 所有產品名稱、徽標和品牌均為其各自所有者的財產。 比較僅供參考,反映撰寫時公開可用的信息。

常見問題解答

Tesseract 和 Microsoft OCR 在語言支持方面的比較如何?

Tesseract 支援超過 100 種語言,並提供豐富的語言數據自訂選項,使其高度多樣化。微軟 OCR 通過 Azure 認知服務提供多語言支持,允許通過雲端擴展語言處理能力。

哪種 OCR 工具更適合與 C# 專案整合?

微軟 OCR 通過 Azure 認知服務可以無縫整合到 C# 專案中,提供雲端可擴展性。Tesseract 可以使用 Tesseract.NET 包裝器進行整合。作為替代,IronOCR 提供了與 C# 專案輕鬆整合的功能,並包含針對 .NET 開發者的額外功能。

使用 Microsoft OCR 的主要優勢是什麼?

Microsoft OCR 通過 Azure 認知服務的雲端系統提供高準確性、擴展性和多語言支持,使用深度神經網絡進行文本識別。

是什麼讓 Tesseract OCR 適合於自訂化?

Tesseract OCR 是開源軟體,提供豐富的自訂化選項,使開發人員能夠將其適應各種專案需求。它允許進行自訂語言訓練以及識別設置的微調。

與 Tesseract 和 Microsoft OCR 相比,IronOCR 如何增強 C# 專案?

IronOCR 提供輕鬆整合、高準確性和多語言支持,具備高級功能,如圖像預處理與 PDF 文本提取。它旨在無縫用於 .NET 應用程序,為開發者提供直觀接口。

選擇 C# 的 OCR 工具時應考慮哪些因素?

選擇 C# 的 OCR 工具時,應考慮語言支持、整合便捷性、自訂選項、擴展性和特定專案需求等因素。Tesseract 適合自訂化,Microsoft OCR 適合雲端擴展性,而 IronOCR 則適合與 .NET 的輕鬆整合。

IronOCR 能否用於將圖像轉換為 C# 應用程序中的文本?

是的,IronOCR 可以用於在 C# 應用程序中將圖像轉換為文本。它支持多種圖像格式,並在文本識別方面提供高準確性,對開發人員來說是個可靠的選擇。

Kannaopat Udonpant
軟體工程師
在成為软件工程師之前,Kannapat 從日本北海道大學完成了環境資源博士學位。在追逐學位期间,Kannapat 還成為了生產工程系一部份——汽車机器人实验室的成員。2022 年,他利用他的 C# 技能加入 Iron Software 的工程團隊, 專注於 IronPDF。Kannapat 珍惜他的工作,因为他直接向编写大部分 IronPDF 使用的代码的开发者学习。除了同行学习,Kannapat 还喜欢在 Iron Software 工作的社交十环。当他不编写代码或文档时,Kannapat 通常在他的 PS5 上打游戏或重看《The Last of Us》。